Hi Justin,
yes, I have ordered a new board from Farnell to see what happens, it arrived today.
My FRDM-KL25Z board had the V1.09 bootloader (the old one). This happened to me (please if this is the same for you):
a) originally plugin in the board, the small green LED came up, and board was recognized properly
b) powering it up in BOOTLOADER mode (Reset pressed), the board came up as BOOTLOADER, then the green small LED is off for a while, then blinks an error code, then off again, etc
c) in BOOTLOADER mode, clicking on the info.html file, it shows a version of 0.00 for the application in the web browser
d) powering the board normally, it does not enumerate, and the small green LED is always off (board bricked)
Same for you?
Erich