Hi @LRawlyk
Thank you for reaching out!
Let me provide my first recommendation, so you could double check.
In the device selection, please try to select the Allow security option option for your part. Here is an example for the Segger J-Link commander. I do not know about the tools that you are using, but please ensure to select that option, per my experience, with this it will allow you to manipulate FSEC.

Just beware of the MEEN, the if the mass erase is not enabled, you won't be able to write a new image with the FSEC enabled again.
I hope this could help you!
Diego