Hello Nicole,
Have you read the application AN3919 note on the tap detection? It can be helpful for you application.
Per the document, the time period of a tap event if about 10ms.

With an ODR of 12.5Hz, your time resolution is equal to 8.3ms. This subsampling does not allow to efficiently catch the tap event (it really depends on the phase beteween the tap event and the MMA8652 clock).
I do not recommand to use this feature at 12.5Hz. Usually we use 200 Hz for tap detection.
You may use the transient detection mechanism with the high pass filter on, but at this ODR, I'm not expecting good results.
I supose you configured the MODS (CTRL_REG2) to 0b11 (low power). There is no other way to reduce the current consumption without changing the ODR. Eventually, you can trig the Auto-Wake up with another interrupt fonction. I mean, you can set the ASLP rate to a lower frequency, when it detectes a motion, it switches to wake mode but you will have a time latency between the wake up event and the tap detection enablement.
Can you give more information/details about your usecase/application. Where do you want to integrated the MMA8552?
Regards,
Anthony