topic Re: sdmmc hangs on SD_Init() in MCUXpresso SDK

sdmmc hangs on SD_Init()

JohnU — Mon, 03 Jul 2017 08:22:46 GMT

Hi,

I test FSL sdmmc on OM13092 LPCXpresso54608 using sdcard_polling example (SDK 2.2.0).

I have found it hangs with an old Toshiba SDHC card (SD-F04G 0742 TL8159V).

Backtrace:

SD_Init()

SD_SetDriverStrength()

SD_SelectFunction()

SD_SwitchFunction()

SDIF_TransferFunction()

SDIF_TransferBlocking()

SDIF_TransferDataBlocking()

dmaStatus = 0xA000 and does not change.

Previous command SD_SetBlockSize(64bytes) is successful. It hangs after kSD_Switch command sent (R1 response[0]=0x900). It can't handle DMA data transfer finish correctly (SDIF_TransferDataBlocking()).

Card data:

RawCid Details:{469793351, 833741708, 1144009799, 39079251}

RawCsd Details:{171966589, 503283584, 1532559360, 1074659378}

RawScr Details:{45416448, 402739458}

ocr 0xc0ff8000

Is it known problem?

best regards

Re: sdmmc hangs on SD_Init()

soledad — Tue, 11 Jul 2017 20:18:17 GMT

Hi,

I found the below thread: sdmmc SD_Write()/SD_Read() failed with ATP card , is the same issue?

in the thread sdmmc eMMC Decode CID properly did you find the solution to this issue?

Regards

Sol

Re: sdmmc hangs on SD_Init()

JohnU — Tue, 11 Jul 2017 23:26:47 GMT

Hi,

no, each of the issues is separate.

The sdmmc library does not support the SD card properly.

Yet another SD card initialization (Sandisk microSD 2GB card) fails on SD_SelectBusTiming() in the file sdmmc/src/fsl_sd.c.

Here is a workaround but I didn't investigate a real reason:

@@ -1058,6 +1058,9 @@ static status_t SD_SelectBusTiming(sd_card_t *card)
             {
                 card->currentTiming = kSD_TimingSDR25HighSpeedMode;
                 card->busClock_Hz = HOST_SET_CARD_CLOCK(card->host.base, card->host.sourceClock_Hz, SD_CLOCK_50MHZ);
+            } else {
+                /* workaround for Sandisk microSD 2GB card */
+                return kStatus_Success;
             }
         }

Moreover sdmmc library examples seem not to be robust enough for SDIF + SD cards:

sdmmc/port/fsl_host.c
@@ -150,7 +150,7 @@ static status_t SDIF_TransferFunction(SDIF_Type *base, sdif_transfer_t *content)
     do
     {
         error = SDIF_TransferNonBlocking(base, &g_sdifHandle, &dmaConfig, content);
-    } while (error == kStatus_SDIF_SyncCmdTimeout);
+    } while (error == kStatus_SDIF_SyncCmdTimeout);//why hangs forever in the loop in some cases?
     if ((error != kStatus_Success) || (false == EVENT_Wait(kEVENT_TransferComplete, EVENT_TIMEOUT_TRANSFER_COMPLETE)) ||
         (!g_sdifTransferSuccessFlag))

Do you happen to know whether sdmmc library upgrade is planned in a next SDK version?

best regards

Re: sdmmc hangs on SD_Init()

Eli_H — Mon, 07 Aug 2017 18:33:56 GMT

Please see this thread:

https://community.nxp.com/message/931558

If you are using the SDRAM on the LPCXpresso board with the pin mux settings given the SD card examples, you will get some intermittent problems. The fix is some pin mux adjustments.

Re: sdmmc hangs on SD_Init()

JohnU — Mon, 07 Aug 2017 23:42:27 GMT

Thanks Eli.

Pinmux is set according to the errara. But probably your hint helps others.

Described issue seems also related to SD specifications, eg. Part 1 Physical Layer, Simplified Specification version 2.00.

Some SD cards works, some not - especially older controllers.

kind regards

Re: sdmmc hangs on SD_Init()

carstengroen — Wed, 27 Sep 2017 13:59:40 GMT

I'm seeing the same problems here with older cards, any plans on fixing this so we can start using the SDK code "for real" ??

My original thread: https://community.nxp.com/thread/461018

Re: sdmmc hangs on SD_Init()

ben11 — Fri, 11 May 2018 01:40:29 GMT

Hi,

Has anyone found a fix for this issue yet? I'm having the same issue on two separate SD cards.

Cheers,

Ben