LPC MicrocontrollersのトピックRe: LPC55xx SDK: usb driver not working with compiling optimization -O2

LPC55xx SDK: usb driver not working with compiling optimization -O2

cgarcia — Thu, 10 Jun 2021 07:23:20 GMT

I downloaded SDK_2.9.1_LPCXpresso55S69 from MCUXpresso SDK Builder, target board LPC55S69 EVK.

From SDK I imported usb device example: lpcxpresso55s69_dev_cdc_vcom_bm, the example is working as expected but if compile optimization is set to O2 then the demo doesn't work.

someone has some idea how to make usb device driver works even with max compile optimization?

I attached dev_cdc_vcom_bm example as reference.

Thanks,

-Carlos

Re: LPC55xx SDK: usb driver not working with compiling optimization -O2

cgarcia — Sat, 12 Jun 2021 22:41:08 GMT

I found the issue in usb example demo coming form SDK_2.9.1_LPCXpresso55S69.

At initialization there is the following code:

/* enable usb0 host clock */
CLOCK_EnableClock(kCLOCK_Usbhsl0);
/*According to reference mannual, device mode setting has to be set by access usb host register */
*((uint32_t *)(USBFSH_BASE + 0x5c)) |= USBFSH_PORTMODE_DEV_ENABLE_MASK;
/* disable usb0 host clock */
CLOCK_DisableClock(kCLOCK_Usbhsl0);

it looks to be a WA, this section of code looks to be not a good practice programming therefore optimized code is not doing exactly what is expected to do.

The solution I found:

volatile uint32_t usbfsh_offset=0x5c;
/* enable usb0 host clock */
CLOCK_EnableClock(kCLOCK_Usbhsl0);
/*According to reference mannual, device mode setting has to be set by access usb host register */
*((uint32_t *)(USBFSH_BASE + usbfsh_offset)) |= USBFSH_PORTMODE_DEV_ENABLE_MASK;
/* disable usb0 host clock */
CLOCK_DisableClock(kCLOCK_Usbhsl0);

There is a lot of examples applying same WA as bad practice of coding at SDK_2.9.1_LPCXpresso55S69/boards/lpcxpresso55s69/usb_examples.

I hope this contributes to NXP team and take it for consideration for demo quality.

Re: LPC55xx SDK: usb driver not working with compiling optimization -O2

emblink182 — Wed, 28 Feb 2024 18:19:13 GMT

Thanks cgarcia for the solution, you saved a lot of my time!

Re: LPC55xx SDK: usb driver not working with compiling optimization -O2

sajid — Wed, 04 Sep 2024 09:56:53 GMT

Hi, Greetings.
I'm using an LPC5516 for my project, which also makes use of HS-USB.
USB was operational at first, and there was no optimisation level.
After that, I adjusted the optimisation level to O2, and it was functioning as well.
Following my transition to O2, I made a single code modification: I commented out a debug PRINTF in a different file that has nothing to do with USB. Suddenly, USB stopped working, meaning Device Manager could not recognise it.
Reverting to the previous modification made the USB working.

Would someone kindly assist me in solving this issue?

Re: LPC55xx SDK: usb driver not working with compiling optimization -O2

emblink182 — Wed, 04 Sep 2024 16:57:10 GMT

Hi @sagid
I had a similar problem with USB and O2 optimization and was able to solve it.
Please take a look at this topic.

https://community.nxp.com/t5/LPC-Microcontrollers/LPC55s28-SDK-USB-example-are-not-working-with-O2-optimization/m-p/1870128#M56117