8-bit MicrocontrollersのトピックRe: 13213board-MyStarNetworkApp with Beaconning

13213board-MyStarNetworkApp with Beaconning

plapla — Wed, 22 Aug 2007 08:51:07 GMT

Hi, I've just add beacon in MyStarNetworkApp but it didn't work.

13213 SRB showed error message "Scan did not find suitable coordinator".

After Passive scan,I think the "resultListSize" is empty so it can't process this code.

Anybody please help.

Re: 13213board-MyStarNetworkApp with Beaconning

Spell — Mon, 27 Aug 2007 14:16:20 GMT

Hi plapla,

take a look in this thread:
http://forums.freescale.com/freescale/board/message?board.id=8BITCOMM&message.id=6438#M6438

regards, Filippo

Re: 13213board-MyStarNetworkApp with Beaconning

plapla — Tue, 28 Aug 2007 11:57:51 GMT

I didn't use router in this application, there're only coordinator and device.

It can't associate and it seems the device didn't receive anything from coordinator.

Please show me how to setting up the coordinator and the device.

Re: 13213board-MyStarNetworkApp with Beaconning

Spell — Tue, 28 Aug 2007 21:26:17 GMT

In the Coordinator code you must set the Beacon Order and the SuperFrame Order, for example BO = 6 and SO = 2.

In the End Device code you must set the scan duration correctly and change the function App_HandleScan for associate to a beacon coordinator

Re: 13213board-MyStarNetworkApp with Beaconning

plapla — Thu, 30 Aug 2007 17:05:21 GMT

MyStarNetworkApp did not support beacon-network

so I've programming in MyWirelessAppEx07 to support more than 1 device,

but the second device didn't receive short address.

They're associate but the second device can't transmit/receive data.

Do I have to set beacon Tx offset or anything else which is not in MyWirelessAppEx07?

Thank you inadvance.

Re: 13213board-MyStarNetworkApp with Beaconning

Spell — Thu, 30 Aug 2007 19:19:11 GMT

If the second end device didn't receive short address it wasn't correctly associate.

However in MyWirelessAppEx07 the beacon order and the superframe order is setted during the creation of a new project with beekit. For support more than 1 device you must change in PAN coordinator code the function that responde to an association request, I don't remeber which is sorry

Re: 13213board-MyStarNetworkApp with Beaconning

plapla — Mon, 03 Sep 2007 16:30:02 GMT

Hi Spell!

I've already change the change the short address part in the coordinator

but it still have a problem so I increase the BEACON_ORDER and SUPERFRAME_ORDER

from 5-3 to 10-10 (is it too much?).They're all associate now.

They can transmit and receive data but it is very slowly when device waiting from the coordinator.

What do you think about it?

Re: 13213board-MyStarNetworkApp with Beaconning

Spell — Mon, 03 Sep 2007 17:10:42 GMT

A beacon order value of 10 mean that the duration of the beacon interval is approximately 15 sec ( T = (960*(2^Order))*16E-6)....

Re: 13213board-MyStarNetworkApp with Beaconning

plapla — Tue, 04 Sep 2007 09:39:49 GMT

Now I've finished beaconStarNetwork and I'm following your Router project in the early thread.

I wonder that the device have to associate to the Pan coordinator or not.

and how the device obtain short address ? from Pan cooordinator or Router?

Re: 13213board-MyStarNetworkApp with Beaconning

Spell — Tue, 04 Sep 2007 15:30:44 GMT

The end device can obtain short address from router or from coordinator, it depends on who it is associated.

Re: 13213board-MyStarNetworkApp with Beaconning

plapla — Tue, 04 Sep 2007 17:35:28 GMT

Thank you Spell.

If there are Pan coordinator, Router and device, how the device choose one of them to associate or it can associate to either.

I've test them and found that the device didn't associate to the router but associate to the Pan coordinator.(They're in the same range)

I've tried again by switch on only Pan coordinator and router to make them associate and then I switch off the Pan coordinator, and switch on the device.

The device can not find a suitable Pan coordinator.(In the Passive scan)

Help please.

Re: 13213board-MyStarNetworkApp with Beaconning

Spell — Tue, 04 Sep 2007 21:42:17 GMT

First, if you have the PAN coordinator and the router in the same range you must set the end device for only associate with the router.
Second, are you sure that during the passive scan the end device finds router and pan coordinator?If you have set correctly BO, SO and macTreemodeStartTime the end device should find the router too.

For set correctly macTreemodeStartTime value use the following file

Re: 13213board-MyStarNetworkApp with Beaconning

plapla — Thu, 06 Sep 2007 14:58:30 GMT

Thanks Spell!. This BeaconCalculator is very useful.

I found that SetRequest of TreemodeStartTime is not success

and I got error InvalidParameter 0xE8. In MAC PHY software user guide

show this problem come from setting Incorrect Treemode Start Time.

But I'm sure my value's correct.

BO=6,SO=1 --->TreemodeStartTime=1982~59458

I've set it to MinValue, MaxValue ,2500 and 3000.

Any other causes that I should check?

Re: 13213board-MyStarNetworkApp with Beaconning

Spell — Thu, 06 Sep 2007 16:36:08 GMT

I don't know, I think the problem is only to set correctly this three parameters.
Try with different values, sorry but I don't remember which values I have used

regards, filippo

Re: 13213board-MyStarNetworkApp with Beaconning

plapla — Wed, 12 Sep 2007 11:06:40 GMT

I've solved the recent problem by setting gMacPibBeaconOrder,SuperFrameOrder in StateHandleScanPassiveConfirm.(I've set it in StateStartRouter in the last time -_-")

but the device still can't associate with the router.

I wonder the coordinator and router send their beacon because they've never detect

MLME-BEACON-START.indication

MLME-BEACON-NOTIFY.indication

MLME-BEACON-START.indication

when the device start associate should the coordinator and router receive Asso-Indication in the same time , my coordinator got it but router've never and device receive long address from coordinator so it start passive scan again to receive short address from the router.

I've already set RxOnWhenIdle = 0x02 but it seems received nothing from the device.

Message Edited by plapla on 2007-09-12 05:16 AM

Re: 13213board-MyStarNetworkApp with Beaconning

Spell — Wed, 12 Sep 2007 14:22:52 GMT

plapla wrote:
when the device start associate should the coordinator and router receive Asso-Indication in the same time

No, when the device perform the passive scan find two possible association, one with coordinator and one with router. After that it choose with wich associate and send to it the association request. Try to change the function HandleScanCofirm for send the association request only to the router...

I don't know if I have been clear, sorry for bad english

regards, Filippo

Re: 13213board-MyStarNetworkApp with Beaconning

plapla — Thu, 13 Sep 2007 15:19:15 GMT

It is very very clear, thanks a lot.

My problem in HandlePassiveScan has solved and it start sendind associate-request.

The Router sent associate response and then it got Synchronization-Loss.LossReason is no_beacon.

What does it mean? The router didn't received a beacon from the PAN coordinator, isn't it?

I've changed BO, SO and treemodeStartTime in many values but I'm still have a problem.

Re: 13213board-MyStarNetworkApp with Beaconning

Spell — Thu, 13 Sep 2007 16:58:17 GMT

I had the same problem and I have solved it after many and many trying...
You must have much patience and try many values

Re: 13213board-MyStarNetworkApp with Beaconning

plapla — Thu, 13 Sep 2007 17:46:15 GMT

It means the problem's from these only values?

Could you tell me which value you use in your network?

Thank you in advance.

Re: 13213board-MyStarNetworkApp with Beaconning

Spell — Thu, 13 Sep 2007 19:05:33 GMT

Sorry but now I'm not using MAC codebase anymore and beacon tree network topology.
I didn't remember which values I've used...